Missouri appeals court reinstates $4 million verdict for trans student against school district

An Appeals Court in the Western District of Missouri reinstated a jury verdict against a school district that allegedly denied a transgender person use of male restroom and locker room facilities.

John Ransom is a Lion contributor and a national political writer and editor whose work has appeared in The Epoch Times, at Townhall.com, Newsmax, the Daily Caller and IBT.

The plaintiff, who was transitioning from female to male in high school, alleged in a 2015 lawsuit that the Blue Springs School District (BSSD) denied equal access to facilities under the Missouri Human Rights Act (MHRA).

In 2022, a jury found in favor of the teen and awarded $4.2 million in damages. But the trial judge overturned the verdict, saying that the plaintiff failed to prove the charges at the hearings.

However, the appeals court cited Bostock v. Clayton County in reversing the trial judge’s decision. 

Bostock is a recent decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that is helping President Joe Biden redefine the legal meaning of “sex” to mean gender identity.

Notably, Bostock was narrowly framed for cases of employment discrimination, not bathroom usage.  

“For an employer to discriminate against employees for being homosexual or transgender, the employer must intentionally discriminate against individual men and women in part because of sex,” wrote Justice Neil Gorsuch in the Bostock text used by the appeals court to justify its decision on behalf of the plaintiff.

Critics of the Bostock decision have claimed it will be used as the thin edge of the wedge that will radically redefine gender identity into a protected class of people.

• Celebrate Thanksgiving on November 27th!
  Thanksgiving is a time when Americans pause to honor the blessings of freedom, family, and faith that define our nation. It’s a day to remember the courage of those who built this country and to give thanks for the opportunities… Read more: Celebrate Thanksgiving on November 27th!
• NewsTalkSTL Holiday Food Drive goes through December 21st
  NewsTalkSTL has teamed up with the St. Louis County Republican Central Committee to do a food drive benefiting Feed My People. The food drive started on Monday, November 10th, and goes through December 21st. The Holiday Food Drive barrels can… Read more: NewsTalkSTL Holiday Food Drive goes through December 21st
• After 3-Day Trial, Oregon Judge Keeps National Guard on Ice While She Drafts Final Ruling
  Susie Moore, Redstate As the Trump administration does legal battle in multiple jurisdictions over its federalization and deployment of National Guard troops, it’s receiving significant pushback from the judiciary. In Oregon, we’ve already seen District Judge Karin Immergut issue multiple… Read more: After 3-Day Trial, Oregon Judge Keeps National Guard on Ice While She Drafts Final Ruling
• Where Are the Gas Chambers?
  Vic Porcelli, Redstate “Trump is Hitler.” “The Republican Party are Nazis.” “ICE is the Gestapo.” We hear these cries almost nonstop. Beyond the fact that none of those claims is remotely true, they’re also horrendous and deeply insensitive accusations. If… Read more: Where Are the Gas Chambers?
• Cottonwood Gunners Veterans Benefit at 9 Mile Garden: Nov. 15
  The Cottonwood Gunners came on The Vic Porcelli Show to talk about their third annual campaign to benefit our great veterans! This year’s event is outdoors at the awesome 9 Mile Garden venue in Affton on Saturday, November 15, from… Read more: Cottonwood Gunners Veterans Benefit at 9 Mile Garden: Nov. 15